Best External Hard Drive for Backup, Games, Files or Video
Backups want a big hard drive, video and file moves want an SSD, and consoles need neither kind of speed. What each costs per terabyte.
A hard drive for what you are keeping, a portable SSD for what you are working on. The price gap has become too wide to ignore: Seagate’s own store sells the Expansion Desktop 20TB at $499.99, which is $25 a terabyte, and the cheapest in-stock portable SSD we found on a maker’s store, Samsung’s T5 EVO 4TB, costs $145 a terabyte.
For backups at home we would buy that 20TB Seagate. For carrying work around or editing video, the Samsung T9 2TB at $489.99. PlayStation and Xbox owners have a catch no drive can fix, and for them the cheapest big USB drive is the right one.
Some links on this page go to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
What a terabyte costs on the makers’ stores
| Drive | Type | Size | Store price | Per terabyte |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seagate Expansion Desktop | Desktop hard drive | 20TB | $499.99 | $25 |
| WD My Passport | Portable hard drive | 6TB | $404.99 | $67 |
| WD My Passport | Portable hard drive | 5TB | $349.99 | $70 |
| OWC Mercury Elite Pro | Desktop hard drive | 20TB | $1,399.99 | $70 |
| OWC Mercury Elite Pro | Desktop hard drive | 4TB | $388.99 | $97 |
| Samsung T5 EVO | Portable SSD, 460MB/s | 4TB | $579.99 | $145 |
| Samsung T9 | Portable SSD, 2,000MB/s | 2TB | $489.99 | $245 |
| Samsung T7 | Portable SSD, 1,050MB/s | 4TB | $1,094.99 | $274 |
| Samsung T7 Shield | Portable SSD, 1,050MB/s, IP65 | 2TB | $574.99 | $287 |
| OWC Express 1M2 | Portable SSD, USB4 | 2TB | $699.99 | $350 |
Portable hard drives are what most people picture, and WD’s own store is the one place we found them priced and in stock. The My Passport is $209.99 for 2TB, $304.99 for 4TB, $349.99 for 5TB and $404.99 for 6TB. The 1TB lists at $184.99 but was sold out, and $25 more buys double the space anyway. Seagate lists the LaCie Rugged USB-C at $149.99 for 2TB and $239.99 for 5TB, which is $48 a terabyte at the larger size, and marks every capacity out of stock. It prints no price for the Expansion Portable or the One Touch and points buyers to resellers.
Backups: buy far more space than you think
The 20TB size is the bargain in Seagate’s range, at $499.99 against its usual $629.99. Apple’s advice for Time Machine is a drive of at least twice your Mac’s storage, and the same sum works for a Windows machine using File History, because old versions of files pile up. The Expansion Desktop needs mains power through its adapter, connects over USB 3.0 and carries a warranty of 12 months in Seagate’s product data, which is short for something you are trusting with everything. Seagate Expansion Desktop 20TB on Amazon
The OWC Mercury Elite Pro is the same idea with a 7200RPM drive inside and three years of cover on that drive, one on the enclosure. At 20TB, $1,399.99 is hard to defend. The 4TB at $388.99 is poor value unless you specifically want the longer warranty, since $111 more buys 16TB more from Seagate.
A backup that travels, or has to run from a laptop’s USB port with no adapter, means a portable hard drive. Our pick is the WD My Passport: WD sells it from 1TB to 6TB, gives it a three-year limited warranty, and adds password protection with 256-bit AES encryption, which matters on a drive small enough to lose. WD My Passport on Amazon
One drive next to the computer protects you from a dead laptop and nothing else. Fire and burglars take both. Keep a second copy somewhere else, or look at a home cloud drive you can reach from anywhere if you would like the copy to happen by itself.
PS5 and Xbox: storage, not speed
No USB drive will run a current-generation game, however fast it is. Sony says plainly that PS5 games cannot be played from USB extended storage and have to be copied back to the console first. PS4 games do run from it. The drive must be 250GB to 8TB, at SuperSpeed USB 5Gbps or later, plugged in without a hub, and setting it up erases it.
That 8TB ceiling rules out the 20TB Seagate on a PS5. A 5TB WD My Passport at $349.99 does the job, and a dear SSD only shortens the copy back.
Xbox Series X and S work the same way. Xbox’s own comparison shows USB 3.1 drives playing Xbox One, Xbox 360 and original Xbox games but not games optimised for Series X|S. Those need a Storage Expansion Card in the slot at the back of the console, and Seagate’s page for its card prints no price. Seagate’s Game Drive for Xbox is listed at $139.99 for 2TB and $219.99 for 5TB, marked out of stock; it is a USB hard drive with a green light on it, so buy whichever USB drive is cheaper on the day.
Moving files between computers
Buy the Samsung T9. The 1TB is $287.99 and the 2TB is $489.99, and the larger one is much the better deal. It is rated at up to 2,000MB/s for reads, and the 100GB folder that takes under four minutes on a T5 EVO takes under a minute. Samsung’s footnote says that speed needs a USB 3.2 Gen 2×2 port and cable. On a 10Gb/s port, which is what plenty of laptops have, the port sets the limit and you get roughly what a T7 gives. Samsung T9 2TB on Amazon
The T7 Shield is poor value next to it. The 1TB costs the same $287.99 at half the rated speed, and the 2TB costs $85 more than the T9. Its case is the only reason to choose it: IP65 water and dust resistance, on Samsung’s listing.
For a lot of files that do not move often, buy the T5 EVO 4TB at $579.99. It is a slow SSD, at 460MB/s, and still nearly half the price per terabyte of the T7 4TB at $1,094.99. Samsung T5 EVO 4TB on Amazon
A drive going between a Mac and a Windows PC should be formatted as exFAT, which both read and write. Drives often arrive formatted for one or the other.
Video work: edit on an SSD, archive on a hard drive
Apple’s ProRes white paper puts 4K ProRes 422 HQ at 25 frames a second at about 737Mb/s, or roughly 92MB/s, and about 332GB an hour. That sets the real need. Any SSD here plays several streams of that, so the speed you are paying for shows up when copying: an hour of footage takes about 12 minutes on the T5 EVO and under three on the T9 at its full speed.
The T9 2TB is what we would edit on. Moving up to the OWC Express 1M2, at $469.99 for 1TB and $699.99 for 2TB, makes sense if your computer has a USB4 or Thunderbolt port and your work is heavy enough to use OWC’s claimed 3,836MB/s. It costs $210 more than the T9 at 2TB, so most editors would not get that back. OWC Express 1M2 on Amazon
Skip OWC’s Envoy Pro Elektron. It is $699.99 for 2TB at up to 1,011MB/s, the same money as the Express 1M2 and about $210 more than the faster T9. Samsung’s own USB4 drives, the P7 and P9, are listed at $285.99 and $339.99 for 1TB and marked out of stock.
Finished projects belong on a hard drive, because at 332GB an hour the 20TB Seagate holds about 60 hours of that footage for about the price of a 2TB T9.